Dally received the Conference USA Academic Medal of Honor. He was redshirted at UCF where he earned a 3.8 GPA. He played in the Florida Collegiate League for the Winter Haven Loggerheads. Dally was a four-year letter recipient at Citrus High School where he played first base and pitched. He recorded a 1.50 ERA with 58 strikeouts in 36 innings his senior year. He earned the All-High School Senior Second team honors. He pitched at the Perfect Game 2008 National Underclass Main Event. He played travel baseball for the Orlando Scorpions and was ranked in the top 1000 by Perfect Game.